What's happening?

Alfred Hitchcock Presents: 6x4

The Contest for Aaron Gold

Aaron Gold stays at a summer camp and is being taught ceramics by Bernie Samuelson. Aaron makes a clay figure of a knight for Bernie class. The figure, however, lacks a right arm. Bernie encourages the boy to finish up before his parent’s visit. Aaron brushes off the encouragement and leaves the figure without an arm. Later, the camp director worrying how the camp would look if Aaron appeared to learn nothing in his stay orders Bernie to finish the figure himself. He does so and greatly upsets Aaron. When Aaron’s father arrives on parents day, Bernie is shocked to discover that he is missing his right arm.

Alfred Hitchcock Presents: Season 6 Episode 4
Oct. 18, 1960